Skip to main content

Why does Castle & Crusades Receive so much derision from OSR Gamers?

I'm going to admit that I'm not the most up to speed when it comes to RPG communities. I got started gaming in my older brother's GURPS games. I then started playing Rifts my freshman year of high school (back in 1996). I didn't start playing AD&D 2E until the summer of 1997 when I purchased the BirthRight campaign setting and then the Introduction to AD&D box set from my local Comics & Comix store.

I went through a 3.x phase in 2000-2003 but I felt into HackMaster 4E for a long time. I didn't really get into other games until I played a game of Castle & Crusades at a local gaming con here in Milwaukee the Nexus Game Fair. I really enjoyed it. I found the rules to be simple while giving me the old AD&D 1E/2E feeling that the original and games like HackMaster gave me. At this time I wasn't aware of the OSR movement at all. I'm still not exactly sure what the OSR movement actually is.

Is OSR gaming just about cloning the original rule sets of D&D? Is it only going to be the Tandy of pen and paper gaming? Do we really want a Tandy 1000 or Tandy 2000 product? On the other hand, sometimes I read about the OSR movement being more of a "feeling" or a "way to play" games which is what got me excited. A lot of modern gaming moved away from the games being focused on player action and then based on the players action the "story" unfolds into the story being told being the prime motivator of the system. I hate that. I like games that allow players to quickly get into the action and not get bogged down so they can be creative with what their characters want to do. But, I also don't want the system to be focused on telling the story. I want the system to be more like the physics of the universe they are playing in and dependent on the players actions but no systems that influence the story directly. An example would be beanies from Savage Worlds or Action Points from D&D 3.5.

Anyway, back to Castle & Crusades. I played in a game at Nexus Milwaukee and had a blast. So, I picked up a few books when TLG had a sale and was happy. I agree with +Erik Tenkar that Castle & Crusades is a Rosetta Stone for AD&D. I love that I can easily run any module or monster with Castle & Crusades with minimal changes. But, when I read forums (such as TheRPGSite) when Castle & Crusades is brought up it seems not to be well liked by the OSR intelligentsia. They seem to prefer systems that attempt to clone pre-1991 rules. But, sometimes, they are okay with the DCC RPG but less okay with C&C.

I guess I am always going to be grateful to Castle & Crusades for getting me back into pen & paper gaming and opening up my eyes to games that I wouldn't have played prior to playing in that one C&C game at a con.

Comments

  1. Ask 3 different OSR gamers what the OSR is about & you will likely get 5 different answers. Here are my 2 copper pieces worth on what I see. I see 3 different ways of "Playing OSR" that tend to overlap to varying degrees.

    1st) The guys who play an older edition & to heck with the new stuff.
    2nd) The guys who play a clone of an older edition that has some rules clarifications &/or new rules that the players like.
    3rd) The guys who, regardless of system used, play in the style of the original games which was usually NOT narrative/storytelling type games. No beginning, middle & end, just "Here is your newly made character & an open world, what do you want to do?"

    C&C isn't an "Older Edition" so those guys are out. It is generally too much like "Basic" for the AD&D crowd but too much like "Advanced" for the Moldvay/Cook/BECMI crowd.

    Personally I love Castles & Crusades, although as I get older I am more & more fond of the simplicity of Moldvay/Cook.

    DCC RPG & Goodman Games is doing everything it can to in various ways please the different segments of the OSR community either with the DCC game or the reprints of the older Judges Guild material from the 70s-80s.

    Castles & Crusades tends to get sadly overlooked.

    Just what I am thinking, at this moment though, thanks for the blog.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Discworld Roleplaying Game Review

During the summer of 2016 across various social media platforms I engaged in discussion with other GURPS fans about ways to get more players playing GURPS. I always wanted an easy entry point product for players to get into the system, see how it works, and quickly get into playing the game. Dungeon & Dragons, and many other systems have an introduction boxset that players can buy into and start playing. GURPS has GURPS Lite but that’s a free PDF and really tailored, in my opinion, to experienced gamers. GURPS Lite doesn’t make it easy for players with limited or no experience find their way into GURPS. This leads me into the Discworld Roleplaying Game.

SJ Games released a 2nd edition of their Discworld Roleplaying Game at the end of November 2016. It is the first physical GURPS book release in a few years and currently buying the physical book is the only way to purchase it. The Discworld Roleplaying Game is a hefty tome coming in at 408 pages with a full glossy hardcover and bla…

Happy #GURPSDay

Thursday is #GURPSDay and I wanted to write a post to join in. GURPS is actually the first RPG I ever played. My older brother and his friends played and when he would have them spend the night (they were in high school and I was in elementary through middle school) my parents made them let me join in. It was a lot of fun. Prior to this my gaming experiences were limited to video games, board games, and games like Dragon Strike and Hero's Quest. I loved that GURPS was so free form that I could do whatever I wanted. In High School, I ended up joining a Rifts game my freshman year and then moving into AD&D 2nd Edition. I did get back into GURPS with the release of 4th Edition in the early 2000's but I could never get a group to stick.

Now that I'm (almost) 34 and have a family of my own I have started to wax nostalgic on my past and I had a lot of good times playing GURPS. More than I have had play any other RPG. So I went out and purchased the characters book as well a…

Can I run a blog with only an iPad and a smartphone?

Right now the only laptop my family owns my wife uses for school. I have the 9.7” iPad Pro with the Apple Smart Keyboard. My other mobile device is the LG V30. I’m wondering how functional running a blog will be using only this iPad and my smartphone. I’m going to give it a go. If I keep up with blogging and get any sort of audience I’d be willing to invest in better technology but I seem to do okay typing with the iPad Pro keyboard just fine.